Introduction

Canada Bread, a renowned bread producer and distributor, has recently faced a monumental penalty of $50 million from the Ontario Superior Court. The fine was imposed as a result of the company's involvement in a criminal price-fixing scheme, artificially inflating the wholesale prices of fresh commercial bread. This groundbreaking ruling marks the highest price-fixing fine ever imposed by a Canadian court. In this article, we delve into the details surrounding the case, highlighting the consequences, key players, and the ongoing efforts to combat price-fixing in Canada's competitive landscape.  

Canada Bread's Guilty Plea and Price-Fixing Scheme

Canada Bread admitted to four counts of price-fixing under the Competition Act, revealing their collaboration with competitor Weston Foods (Canada) to raise prices on various bagged and sliced bread products, including sandwich bread, hot dog buns, and rolls. This illicit agreement resulted in two significant price increases, occurring in 2007 and 2011.  

Transition of Ownership and Cooperation with Investigation

During the period of price-fixing, Canada Bread was under the ownership of Maple Leaf Foods, but it's worth noting that the individuals responsible for the illegal activities are no longer associated with the company. Currently owned by Grupo Bimbo, Canada Bread's involvement in the criminal scheme prompted an investigation by the Competition Bureau. In recognition of the company's full cooperation, the Bureau recommended leniency in sentencing, pursuant to their Leniency Program.  

Record-Breaking Fine and Ongoing Investigation

The Ontario Superior Court imposed a $50 million fine on Canada Bread, signifying a significant milestone in the Competition Bureau's ongoing investigation into price-fixing practices. This record-breaking penalty, albeit reduced due to the company's cooperation and guilty plea, serves as a stern warning to other firms engaged in anti-competitive behaviors. Furthermore, the Bureau continues to scrutinize other companies, such as Metro, Sobeys, Wal-Mart Canada, Giant Tiger Stores, and Maple Leaf Foods, as part of their commitment to upholding fair market conditions.  

Importance of the Bread Industry and Criminal Offenses

The price-fixing of bread, an essential food staple in Canadian households, is considered a grave criminal offense. Matthew Boswell, Commissioner of Competition, emphasized the Bureau's dedication to pursuing individuals and organizations involved in such activities. The objective is to deter price-fixing and maintain a level playing field for the benefit of Canadian consumers.  

Involvement of Weston Foods and Loblaw Companies

In December 2017, Weston Foods and Loblaw Companies, both subsidiaries of George Weston Limited (GWL), publicly acknowledged their participation in an "industry-wide price-fixing arrangement." The arrangement entailed coordinated manipulation of both retail and wholesale bread prices. Weston, Loblaw, and GWL were granted immunity from prosecution in exchange for their complete cooperation with the Competition Bureau's investigation.  

Conclusion

Canada Bread's $50 million fine serves as a landmark case in combating price-fixing in Canada's bread industry. The penalty demonstrates the Competition Bureau's unwavering commitment to ensuring fair and transparent market conditions. As investigations into other companies continue, the Bureau remains dedicated to pursuing those engaged in anti-competitive practices. Through stringent enforcement and leniency programs, the goal is to safeguard the interests of Canadian consumers and maintain a healthy and competitive market environment.

See our Blog